Consulting

I'm available for consulting.
You can reach me at info@reidrosefelt.com

About Me

I've worked as a film publicist and film marketer on over a hundred films, from "Stranger Than Paradise" to "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon and "Precious."  My full bio is here.

Click HERE for an interview with me on the Business2Community website.

Swindled by AT&T: My $1723 iPhone Bill for working on “Tabloid”

Sunday, October 03, 2010

I’m sorry, but this isn’t a film post, a memoir, a musing, and it’s definitely not funny. 

I went to the Toronto Film Festival for 5 days and 4 hours and received a $1524 AT&T bill for data charges on top of the $199 paid for the first 200 MB. A total of $1723.

I am very angry about this and would greatly appreciate it if any of my readers would tweet this and post it on FaceBook.  

I’ve learned since that bills like these are a commonplace with AT&T. (See the videos below.)  Here’s why:AT&T-Charges-blueThe 200MB plan is pro-rated by the dates of the monthly plan, which in my case was Aug 17th to September 16th. In order to get all 200 MB I had to backdate to August 17th  Otherwise I would have paid $199 for 50 MB.

I knew in advance I was going to use a lot of data because I was going to be working at the Toronto Film Festival setting up publicity for “Tabloid,” a new movie by Academy Award-winning filmmaker Errol Morris. I would always be on the run, needing to receive phone calls and email everywhere and at all times.  Worse, when I got there I discovered there was no wireless—only wired—internet service in my hotel room and the interview suite that was used for Mr. Morris’s interviews.

iPhone-blueI was told that the AT&T iPhone app worked in Canada by an AT&T operator. The application had a line graph that tracked international usage. But as AT&T cannot finish their accounting for international charges until 90 days after the data is used, it’s impossible for them to display charges they haven’t received yet. There’s no possible way it can work and they know that.

If AT&T hadn’t provided the app, I wouldn’t have been comforted by the low readings it was providing me.   I wouldn’t have had any idea how much data I was using, and that would have put the fear of God into me.  Still,  I did try to turn the data off—via “Airplane Mode” and changing the settings—but this shut off the phone too. What I didn’t know, and no one told me until afterwards, is that if I turned off “roaming” I could have had telephone service without data. I didn’t imagine that it was possible to use a phone in a foreign country without turning roaming on.

prey-blue When I got on my plane in Canada, the AT&T app said I’d used 120 MB, but after I got home apartment in New York it was a heart attack-inducing 300+ MB.   20 minutes after I shut off my international plan, I received an email and text from AT&T stating that they were suspending my already canceled international data planAND domestic data plan.  The email falsely claimed that I had ignored an earlier text  and email about excessive usage sent to met while I was in Canada.  An operator later confirmed that no such email
or text had been sent.

Eventually I found a sympathetic operator who filed a 4-page application for a full refund.

On Friday I received a text saying  there would be no reduction of any kind.  An  operator confirmed that there would be no explanation for the denial or any possibility of reconsideration.

 

Tags: ,

Comments (38) -

10/4/2010 12:19:14 AM #

I'm so sorry to hear this. Surreal. Is this stuff regulated at all? Just seems like a faustian entrapment nightmare come to hellish life. If you don't pay it, what happens?

Barbara | Reply

10/4/2010 6:50:28 AM #

Actually the real story is so much worse.  The original blog post was three times longer and I had to edit it or no one would ever read it.  The truth is there are many infuriating things that AT&T did that I just didn't have space for. For example, after I found out about the bill they made me wait 11 days before I could present my case. Lot of stressing during those intervening days, let me tell you. I made doubly sure that they should use my home number, as my iPhone doesn't work reliably in my appointment. Of course, after waiting home all day for my  call, it went to my iPhone, which didn't ring.

My attempt to get some justice has taken days of my life, and close to 20 calls with AT&T.  Two of them were an hour or longer.  

What is upsetting to me is that I'm getting all these emails today from friends today who are saying, oh just ask and you'll get your money back, they had a friend that did that.  

The bill is in the hands of the producers of "Tabloid" now.  Hopefully they will pay it.

Reid | Reply

10/5/2010 12:24:43 PM #

What justice?  The bill is entirely justified.  You should have turned off your data.

SKB | Reply

10/21/2010 10:45:38 PM #

I agree..it is justified.When you sign up for a service plan you must sign that you are agreeing to the terms..They cannot just charge things that are not in those terms.I am quite sure they quoted the exact wording in the plan justifying the charges and the price. If you did not like the terms you could have refused to sign and not chosen them as a provider.They should not have to hold the hand of every person who does not read the terms of service or understand the technology or what is and is not billable. You are saying its unfair because you dont agree with the price. but in all honesty you agreed to it, you obviously used what they are charging for.Not once did I read that you did not use the phone.Pay up.

lisa | Reply

11/4/2010 11:24:36 AM #

rarely find anything positive about my mobile plan…
i have family ATT plan (3 blackberrys & 2 iphones)
i added data $15/month/line (for 200MB each…total 1GB for $75)
this week, changed to new family data plan promotion – $25/month shared (2GB total)

- happy with this – paying 1/3 price of previous plan & getting twice the data

edward | Reply

10/4/2010 6:52:10 AM #

Oh I didn't answer your question, Barbara.  I don't know what I will do if the "Tabloid" producers don't pay.  I don't have the money.

Reid | Reply

10/4/2010 9:22:53 AM #

Hey Reid,

If AT&T does not take off the charges, don't pay it, cancel their service & get a better phone & company, file complaints w/ whatever/all agencies that regulate AT & T's business, get the word out re: your AT & T nightmare to the media, & re: the bill, ultimately (like 3 - 6 months from now) you should be able to settle the bill w/ AT & T or a collection agency for a fraction of what they are trying to collect from you now.  I think a publicist is the wrong kind of client for AT & T to mess with Smile

- Sujewa

Sujewa Ekanayake | Reply

10/4/2010 11:49:42 AM #

You need to file a complaint with the FCC. AT&T really, really sucks. But frankly, there is evidence enough all around that practically ALL the cell phone service providers SUCK!  The only recourse is government regulation and oversight to prevent consumer exploitation and fraudulent practices by the carriers. Precisely because of repeated problems like your with cell phone service carriers, web sites such as UGetHeard.com offers templates for you to type your complaint, along with what you would like the company to do. It then forwards the complaint to the company and follows up. Feedback Direct and The Complaint Station, likewise, will send complaints to the appropriate parties and will log in the number of complaints a company receives.
In many other countries of the world, the practices and contracts you see in the U.S. have been outlawed simply because they exploit and abuse the customer.

Richard | Reply

10/8/2010 4:44:28 AM #

Actually the FCC has contacted me. (see above)

Reid | Reply

10/4/2010 11:56:30 AM #

So this happened to me -- but "only" for several hundreds of dollars. The bulk (but by no means all) of the trouble arose from the fact that the AT&T customer service reps told me to turn off the extra voice and data plans I had added for my trip to Canadia as soon as I got home. I did as I was told. This resulted in my being charged for voice and data use for which I had no plan -- because they do their billing so late and I turned these plans off once I was no longer in Canada. The ended up waiving all the charges, but not before I freaked out at them.

oudemia | Reply

10/4/2010 5:32:03 PM #

On the one hand, I certainly have a measure of sympathy for you. On the other hand, dude, seriously, WTF? You're a blogger. You're clearly not technically illiterate. Literally one google search for any rational search terms would have turned up all the information you would have needed about this situation. Instead, you took the assurances of some random person reading off of a script in India or China or something and just assumed you'd be fine. This is called 'not exercising due diligence'. If I were your employer and I were paying the monthly bill, I would be absolutely livid at you.

Okay, yes, I agree that turning off 'roaming' does imply that your phone wouldn't work in a foreign country. That's why the setting is called 'Data Roaming. In the actual iPhone. A little exploration (or a search for the word 'roaming') would have turned that up for you.

Hell, if you wanted to actually solve the problem, you could even have done that: jailbreak your phone, unlock it, and get one of the Rodgers pay-as-you-go SIM cards. Admittedly, that's a lot more than most people want to go through, but it is an option available to you. (Well, maybe. Depending on what version of software you have on your phone at the moment.)

Fred Fnord | Reply

10/8/2010 4:52:55 AM #

I made five calls to AT&T before I left and taped most of them.  They lied to me. If I understand your point correctly, you're saying that if multi-billion dollar companies lie to their customers so as to charge $1500 for three cents worth of data then it is always the customer's fault. They could have gone on the internet.  

What you're forgetting about is that AT&T only sells 200MB worth of data at their low 1300% markup.  After that it is $5 a megabyte.  I had a job to do and they didn't provide me with any way to do it which wouldn't cost a fortune.

Reid | Reply

10/5/2010 11:26:40 AM #

When I travel from Canada to the USA I am warned by text message about my fees. (I have a simple cell with no data.) But international cell phone usage is _very_ expensive, going either way.

Chris J | Reply

10/5/2010 11:28:14 AM #

Well if there is any good news here AT&T is sure to find out about the bad press your post is generating. I knew nothing of your site until Andrew Sullivan over at The Atlantic picked up your story. For what it is worth I plan to pass it along.

AT&T is get some real competition from Verizon and Driod and they can ill afford to give folks more reason's to run the hell away from AT&T.

jsfox | Reply

10/5/2010 11:33:06 AM #

Duh, just turn data roaming off outside the U.S.  Most everyone knows that.

Chaz | Reply

10/8/2010 4:55:17 AM #

Duh, I wasn't on holiday.I was working in a situation where dozens of people needed to reach me every single minute. Journalists who worked with me up there know exactly what I'm talking about.  I couldn't turn off data roaming all the time.

Reid | Reply

10/5/2010 11:43:50 AM #

Are there any companies that offer decent 3G rates for people who need one device to work in both the US and Canada?

Robert | Reply

10/5/2010 11:56:45 AM #

That's a bummer for sure, and no offense, but... I went to France last summer, and I looked into what the data rates were before I went. I quickly learned from others posting the same horror story as you to keep data roaming turned off, and to only use it when I needed, or when I was connected to WiFi.

Did you NOT think that traveling to another country would affect your iPhone rates??  I'm sure you didn't think it'd be as much as it is, but why didn't you spend 5 minutes to Google it?

The Plan-Aheader | Reply

10/5/2010 12:25:31 PM #

That's why I paid $30 and unlocked my iPhone before my trip to Europa.

www.iphoneunlock123.com ... enjoy

Mishka | Reply

10/5/2010 12:29:01 PM #

You should just shut up and pay the bill.  Had you googled "iphone international roaming" this would have been your very first result:

www.wireless.att.com/.../iphone-travel-tips.jsp

asdf | Reply

10/8/2010 5:19:21 AM #

I wish I had read that page I would still have had a giant bill, just not as big as the one I got.  In order to cut my bill I would have had to drastically reduce the quality of my work. I would have turned the phone off in my room and worked in my lobby 25 floors down (where there was wireless) deep into the night People who would have wanted to reach me would not have been able to reach me whenever I was in my room or out on the street. Sometimes those calls are very urgent and I would have missed them.

You don't understand that AT&T does not provide a fair service for someone like me.  They sell a maximum of 200MB.  If they had sold a 500 MB plan I would have paid it.  It would have been prorated and it would have only cost a few hundred dollars.

If you think the internet is the way to help people then what is wrong with more cautionary stories like mine available on the web?  If I wanted to shut up I wouldn't have a blog.

Reid | Reply

11/5/2010 8:18:29 AM #

You know what blows my mind? That, if you have all this work to while out of the country, you don't take and use a lap top instead. Shut your data off, answer your phone calls, use the computer for the rest of the shit. It's not hard. People who don't think ahead have absolutely no right to complain about the messes they get themselves into.

Missy | Reply

11/7/2010 12:48:44 PM #

Sorry to blow your mind, but of course I took a laptop. Hundreds of people had my cell phone number.  I was very rarely in my hotel.  If I shut my phone off, then the entire trip would have been a catastrophe. I spent at least five hours thinking ahead, before I went, talking to AT&T.  What you don't seem to get is that they don't offer a product at a reasonable price for the business I needed to do--so it is expensive, no way around it.  As a for profit company they have every right to charge what they want.

But if you look ahead to two other posts, you will see that the FCC is looking into some of their policies, and that the CEO of AT&T contacted me to give me a 50% refund.  

Reid | Reply

10/5/2010 1:08:43 PM #


First, you can get your AT&T data balance (when in Canada too!) *any time* by dialling *DATA# on your phone.   It's up to the minute, as far as I can tell.    I travel to Canada a lot, and find that tool indispensable.  

Second, the "Usage" meter works pretty well as a backup.

Third, the "roaming" setting you are referring to is called "Data Roaming", and it says those words right next to the button.     Did you not think to at least try it and make a phone call to see if voice still worked?

International data roaming has always been expensive regardless of what carrier you use, though AT&T tends to be the most expensive.  There are special plans for Verizon and Sprint that tend to be more affordable, and Rogers in Canada has a "One Rate" plan that extends to AT&T in the U.S. which is also pretty affordable (and iPhone friendly).   But nevertheless, AT&T US remains the most expensive carrier for roaming.

stu | Reply

10/8/2010 5:03:06 AM #

First of all what you are saying about DATA# is untrue.  Call AT&T and they will confirm to you that they only finalize their charges after 90 days.  

It seems that many of these commentors are on the side of huge corporations and their right to fleece people. You think that these people deserve it because they could have ignored what the company told them on tape and googled it.  

Secondly you seem to think it's great that when I put in a 4-page application for remedy that they make no response to it other than to deny it.  My application was much more detailed than this post.

Reid | Reply

10/5/2010 1:20:42 PM #

The charge are very high and difficult to understand. However, I wonder about a couple of things. One, how much of this is being determined by Rogers, the Canadian provider through which I'm guessing your service was funneled. And second, and more importantly, why did you turn international data roaming on in the first place? The default position is off. I traveled to Canada, and I learned that international data roaming is very expensive and that therefore the default iPhone setting for data roaming is off. So if you elected to turn the feature on, it's not unreasonable to expect you to know what you're getting yourself into, is it?

Charlie Collier | Reply

10/8/2010 5:05:21 AM #

Yes it was off, but I got no email. When I turned it on all my messages immediately came in.  This suggested to me that it had to be on.

Reid | Reply

10/5/2010 1:28:14 PM #

Sorry, but if checking the rates on your cell phone plan didn't occur to you before crossing an international border (even Canada!), I have zero sympathy for your situation.

David | Reply

10/8/2010 5:08:21 AM #

I was completely aware.  I spent hours on this. I talked to five people.  I taped most of them.  They only offered 200MB at their cheap 1300% markup rate.  After that it was $5 a MB.  I needed more data for the job I was hired to do. They don't offer a product for the work I needed to do.  

Reid | Reply

10/8/2010 3:37:29 AM #

We arrived in Toronto about two weeks ago, without setting up an international data plan in advance. We received text messages informing us that the rate for data was $15.36 per MB!  Needless to say we didn't touch the net by phone that week.

What I find "amusing" is that they charge far less for that same megabyte of data when its in the form of a few minutes of voice traffic, a situation where 0.25 second of delay will cause a noticeable dropout.

rjnerd | Reply

10/8/2010 3:41:53 AM #

I sent one email while I was alone, stranded in the Philippines, and it was about 500 USD, even with my [admittedly low-level] international data/phone things [which are still stupidly expensive].

erin | Reply

10/8/2010 7:54:49 PM #

On the iPhone under "Settings->Network" there is a data roaming setting.  It says "Turn data roaming off when abroad to avoid substantial roaming charges when using email, web browsing, and other data services."

That caveat has been there since my first generation 2G only iPhone.  Pretty clear, isn't it?  The setting defaults to "off" so you're forced to see the warning as you set yourself up for trouble.

I suppose the only question might be if one would reasonably consider Canada as "abroad".  But a two minute experiment would have confirmed it for you.

Anyway, I think "swindled" might be a bit harsh.  Nothing was hidden, he made some unwarranted assumptions about how his phone worked when on a different network than AT&T (Rogers).

Chad | Reply

10/9/2010 4:19:39 AM #

If you were just using data on the phone (not tethering), Verizon offers an unlimited international data package for $64.99 for all PDA phones. So if you can part from your iphone next time your traveling, this would be a better option.

A better option | Reply

10/12/2010 8:23:55 AM #

I'm having a similar problem.  

Now I see AT&T is taking advantange of a defect in the iPhone to charge customers more.  If you get in a car and drive, and the spedometer reads 50mph, you expect the car to be traveling at 50mph.  Likewise, if the iPhone indicates that it is in wifi mode, you expect the phone to be in wifi phone.

This is no difference in this an telemarketers calling up the elderly and making a false sale.  AT&T is making profit by preying on the customer.

How does one start a class-action lawsuit?

Mike McMahon | Reply

10/29/2010 4:30:26 AM #

I had AT&T for a year or so and have had no problems, because i had an unlimited data plan for $30 and when i added my two kids and started checking, i was only using 50mb or less.  So i switched to the $15 plan and was happy....UNTIL we all started getting 'you are over' and now another $15 is being charged.  This month my son got that 2 times and we still have until Nov 12th to go!   Of course at first i began to get after them thinking they were doing all kinds of things that we could do at home on wifi for free.  They were profusely saying that they weren't using the data and had no idea why it was charging it.  We then started paying attention.  We went to disney and in the 3 days we were there..I was with them, it jumped 100mb! Almost identical amounts on 2 of our phones, my older daughters 20 and 24, so we aren't talking young kids.  We didn't have our phones on and working for excessive data, even if there was a little checking here and there, what is data supposed to be for?  So we did a little test.  I have a son-in-law with has been an IT guy for over 10 years and we took ONE of our phones and turned it off.  everything you could think of 'push notifications', network..we turn off 'cellular data' turned off all location tracking in safari, etc you name it and we went thru the phone and turned it off.  We then did a 'data useage' check by dialing *3282# at that point.  Then each day we checked the data, interestly it kept going up!  True, not by a lot, maybe 20mb over 3 or 4 days.  But AT&T when i called, said they can't tell where the data is coming from, that would be a 'violation' of my privacy, would I like that?  Well what i would like, is to have someone not charge me for data i am not using.  If there is a problem with the phone, APPLE needs to take care of it.  I however think it is a great way for AT&T to charge and basically it is your word against their's.  How do they get away with that?
If anyone is reading this that can tell me of an agency I can take one of my phone's to and have them verify officially this,  I am so ready to hold AT&T accountable.  Can you imagine the millions of dollars that AT&T is charging customers because they think we have no way to fight back.

Jackie Y. | Reply

10/29/2010 11:06:02 AM #

First of all, perhaps this has to do with the iPhone's new multitasking feature. If you turn off of a program that uses data, it stays on.  You can't turn this new multitasking feature off.

The only thing you can do is to do the two clicks of the bottom button to see what is running and then you hold your finger down until you see the minus (like you're deleting an app) and you delete them off multitasking one by one.  That's the only way to get rid of them.  If you turn your phone off and back on again, all those programs will still be there.

I have no idea how much data the programs use when they are in their multitasking state.  My guess is that they do draw quite a bit depending on what programs you use and that may explain your problem.

I have sent a request into Apple asking if there could be a switch in Settings where the user can turn off Multitasking.  

Do you want me to pass your comment on to the FCC?

Reid | Reply

11/22/2010 6:48:12 PM #

Coming to the US from France, I accidentally turned off my airplane mode for about three minutes and my email downloaded.  This "only" cost me about $50.  Horror stories!  I think when I come back I'll get a pay-as-you-go phone.

Judith Ezekiel | Reply

12/29/2011 12:09:22 PM #

I am no going on an hour and 23 minutes simply trying to pay my ATT phone bill, when I already have it set up on automatic bill pay! ATT can't seem to get it together. "Your time should be spent enjoying life," they say as I'm on hold. Exactly! It should not be spent on hold. I have been transferred to 7 different people, each saying that it's not the correct department. Seriously, it's home service. How complicated is that!?

Jeffrey United States | Reply

Pingbacks and trackbacks (4)+

Add comment




  Country flag
biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading